为进一步提高利群律师的专业水平和实务能力，分享律师的专业成果和办案经验，并充分发挥优秀案例的典型示范作用，2023年2月6日晚，利群所在全所范围内开展2022年度“十大优秀案例”评选活动。

经评选委员会初选，最终在报送的案例中选出18个案例角逐2022年度“十大优秀案例”。

●  杨文杰 台州市委党校法学与公共管理教研室主任

●  朱福高 台州市椒江区人大常委会监察和司法工作委员会主任

●  蒋先章 台州市椒江区司法局副局长

●  王新平律师 台州市律师协会会长、利群所合伙人会议主席

●  尹朝辉律师 利群所副主任、党支部副书记

评选活动开始后，各位律师依次以PPT的形式介绍了案例的基本案情、相关证据、争议焦点等内容，并分享了自己的办案思路与心得体会，也为在座律师今后的办案提供了有益参考。

2022年度“十大优秀案例”

01

报送案例：吴某某诉包某某股权转让纠纷撤回起诉案

报送律师：张  梁

02

报送案例：限定刑事责任能力人李某故意杀人案

报送律师：黄道进、潘  婵

03

报送案例：李某某故意杀人罪二审改判案

报送律师：蔡婉瑛

04

报送案例：台州市杰特瑞卫浴公司与国家知识产权局商标申请驳回复审行政纠纷改判案——在商标申请过程中通过“撤三”复审及诉讼清除商标注册权利障碍

报送律师：毛灵见、江  宁、何良雄

05

报送案例：阮某犯合同诈骗罪二审改判实报实销案

报送律师：黄道进、张罗晗

06

报送案例：国家知识产权局、永源公司与川崎株式会社外观专利权无效行政纠纷二审改判——如何界定一般消费者以及设计空间对一般消费者知识水平和认知能力的影响

报送律师：毛灵见、江  宁、许听雨

07

报送案例：小区业主陈红珍诉次承租人刘海洋、陆琼侵权纠纷案

报送律师：冯  懿、张栩溢

08

报送案例：揭开神秘的面纱—披追偿外衣的“民间借贷”

报送律师：何贤超

09

报送案例：陈某诉某市公安局、某市人民政府治安管理行政处罚及行政复议一案

报送律师：顾奇誌

10

报送案例：陈某某涉嫌生产、销售伪劣产品罪不起诉一案

报送律师：张  梁

优秀的法律案例，实现了法律效果和社会效果的统一，代表着法律人的荣誉和徽章，蕴含着律师的法律智慧、专业水平和办案艺术。利群律师将继续深耕专业，不断总结和积累办案经验，学习和交流业务成果。同时，也期待未来利群所能产生更多优秀案例，以优秀案例传播法治声音，为法治建设贡献力量。

In order to further improve the professional level and practical ability of Liqun Lawyers, share their professional achievements and case handling experience, and fully leverage the typical demonstration role of excellent cases, on the evening of February 6, 2023, Liqun's office conducted the "Top 10 Excellent Cases" selection activity for the year 2022 throughout the entire office.

After the preliminary selection by the selection committee, 18 cases were ultimately selected from the submitted cases to compete for the "Top 10 Excellent Cases" in 2022.

● Yang Wenjie, Director of the Law and Public Management Teaching and Research Office of the Taizhou Municipal Party School

● Zhu Fugao Director of the Supervision and Judicial Work Committee of the Standing Committee of the People's Congress of Jiaojiang District, Taizhou

● Jiang Xianzhang, Deputy Director of Taizhou Jiaojiang District Justice Bureau

● Lawyer Wang Xinping, President of the Taizhou Lawyers Association and Chairman of the Partner Meeting of Liqun Institute

● Deputy Director and Deputy Secretary of the Party Branch of Lawyer Yin Chaohui Liqun Institute

After the selection activity began, the lawyers introduced the basic facts, relevant evidence, and controversial points of the case in the form of PPTs, and shared their case handling ideas and experiences, which also provided useful references for the lawyers present in the future.

Top 10 Excellent Cases in 2022

01

Reported case: Wu sued Bao for the withdrawal of the lawsuit on the dispute over the transfer of equity

Submitted to Lawyer: Zhang Liang

02

Reported case: intentional homicide case of Li, a person with Diminished responsibility

Submitted to lawyers: Huang Daojin, Pan Chan

03

Reported case: Li Moumou's second instance retrial of intentional homicide

Submitted to Lawyer: Cai Wanying

04

Submitted case: Taizhou Jetrui Sanitary Ware Co., Ltd. and the China National Intellectual Property Administration rejected the trademark application for reexamination of the administrative dispute case - in the process of trademark application, the obstacles to trademark registration rights were removed through the "three withdrawal" review and litigation

Submitted to lawyers: Mao Lingjian, Jiang Ning, He Liangxiong

05

Reported case: Ruan Mou's case of contract fraud, second instance judgment change, actual report and sales case

Submitted to lawyers: Huang Daojin, Zhang Luohan

06

Case submitted: the second instance of the administrative dispute over the invalidation of appearance patent between the China National Intellectual Property Administration, Yongyuan Company and Kawasaki Co., Ltd. - how to define the impact of general consumers and design space on their knowledge level and cognitive ability

Submitted to lawyers: Mao Lingjian, Jiang Ning, Xu Tingyu

07

Reported case: Case of infringement dispute between community owner Chen Hongzhen and sub lessee Liu Haiyang and Lu Qiong

Submitted to lawyers: Feng Yi, Zhang Xuyi

08

Case Report: Unveiling the Mysterious Veil - "Private Lending" in the guise of Recovery

Submitted to Lawyer: He Xianchao

09

Reported case: Chen v. Public Security Bureau and People's Government of a certain city, Administrative Penalty and Administrative Reconsideration for Public Security Management

Submitted to Lawyer: Gu Qizhi

10

Reported case: Chen is suspected of not suing for the crime of producing and selling counterfeit and inferior products

Submitted to Lawyer: Zhang Liang

Excellent legal cases achieve the unity of legal and social effects, representing the honor and emblem of legal professionals, and embodying the legal wisdom, professional level, and case handling art of lawyers. Liqun Lawyers will continue to deepen their expertise, continuously summarize and accumulate case handling experience, and learn and exchange business achievements. At the same time, we also look forward to more excellent cases generated by Liqun in the future, spreading the voice of the rule of law through excellent cases, and contributing to the construction of the rule of law.